Vanguard just released a comprehensive retirement income research paper and the findings challenge almost everything most people assume about retirement planning.
Vanguard just released a comprehensive retirement income research paper and the findings challenge almost everything most people assume about retirement planning.
👉 Join Andrew’s FREE Investing for Beginner’s Masterclass: https://event.webinarjam.com/q05p7/register/0o8z9io?webinar_id=21
What You'll Learn in This Episode
Start Here
Join the community built to help you master your money, stay accountable, and reach financial freedom.
👉 Try Master Money Academy FREE for 7 days today!
https://mastermoney.co/join/
👉 Join Andrew’s FREE Investing for Beginners Masterclass
https://event.webinarjam.com/q05p7/register/0o8z9io?webinar_id=21
👉 Join The Master Money Newsletter where you will become smarter with your money in 5 minutes or less per week Here!
https://expert-hustler-605.ck.page/6aa7bb9a79
Partner Deals
Resource/s Mentioned
Episode/s Mentioned
Watch Next
Connect with Garrett
Connect with Andrew
Question for you:
After hearing this episode, what is the one thing you are changing about how you think about retirement income? Drop it in the comments and tell us what you are doing differently starting this week.
Transcript:
A specific amount in your retirement account does not guarantee retirement success. So it's not about your balance, it's about how you're spending that down. Well, someone who has a half million dollar portfolio, maybe they live pretty frugally. Maybe they have a lot of guaranteed income, so they need $10,000 a year from their portfolio to meet their retirement goals.
If you assume zero returns, that portfolio will last 50 years. But if you have $1,000,000 and you're withdrawing $100,000 a year, it only lasts 10 years. So it's not how much you have because, you know, the smaller portfolio in the example I gave lasts five times as long as the $1,000,000 portfolio, which is twice as large.
Reducing your spending rate by just half a percent is one of those things. And the reason this works really comes down to compounding. Know what your numbers are, know where your money's coming from, know what you're going to do. Because if you can start early, these little changes can make a huge difference over a 30 year retirement.
Longevity is actually the bigger risk. If you haven't planned to live a longer time, you're going to run out of money. Anyway, on this episode of the Personal Finance Podcast, we talk about the most important metric when it comes to your retirement.
What's up everybody? And welcome to the Personal Finance Podcast. I'm your host, Andrew, founder of Master money.co, and today on the Personal Finance Podcast, we're going to talk about the only number that matters in retirement. If you guys have any questions, make sure you join the Master Money newsletter by going to mastermoney.co/newsletter.
And don't forget to follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify, YouTube or whatever your favorite podcast cast player is. And if you want to help out the show, consider leaving a five star rating and review on Apple podcast, Spotify or your favorite podcast player. Now, most people think that the hardest part about retirement is saving money.
It isn't. The hard part is what happens after the day after the paycheck stop and the only thing standing between you and the rest of your life is the number in your account. And here's the big question that you might be asking yourself. Well, how much can I spend every single year before running out of money?
If you get this wrong in One Direction, you could die with a fortune that you were too scared to touch. And you may have spent 30 years saying no to the life that you actually worked for. You worked your tail off for this amazing life, and we're too scared to spend the money. Get it wrong in the other direction and you could end up running out of money.
And so This is why we want to have this conversation today. My guest today has spent a career running numbers just like this. Garrett Harbron is the lead researcher and head of Advise Wealth Management Strategies at Vanguard. And he is the mind behind their brand new research principles for retirement income.
When some of the largest financial decisions in your life come down to math and behavior. And this is the person who actually modelled the outcomes. And what he told me genuinely changed how I think about this. A. Half a percent can change how much you can withdraw and add an entire five years to how long your money lasts.
That the thing that most people should fear in retirement is not a market crash, but how long you live. And that there's a window, a quiet window, between when you first retire and when you should be doing raw conversions. We talked about Social Security. We talked about taxes and there are a lot of 6 figure Nuggets in this episode that could really change the way that you think about money.
If you are anywhere near retirement or you are planning out retirements 20 or even 30 years out, this is a conversation to you. This is a conversation that you need to hear. So let's welcome Garrett to the Personal Finance podcast. Awesome.
Well, Garrett, welcome to the Personal Finance Podcast. Thanks, Andrew. Appreciate being here. I'm really excited to have you here because Vanguard just put out this incredible research on retirement income and kind of the way that income impacts people's retirement. And I know our audience is really big on planning for retirement.
They are all of them were, you know, thinking through this a ton when they are going through this process. So first, can you kind of tell us a little bit about yourself, the research that you do, and then we'll dive deeper into some of the questions on this, this research you guys have done? Sure, absolutely. So I work for Vanguard and I lead our advice advised wealth management strategies team, which is a really fancy way of saying I lead the team that does the financial planning, research and thought leadership for Vanguard.
And we decided to take this paper up a little over a year ago. We looked across the horizon of of industry topics and what we realized was that while there were a lot of pieces out there that talked about retirement income in in very narrow sleeves, there wasn't anything out there that really kind of brought it all together in a way that would help investors make decisions about how to generate income in retirement.
You know, we've got a lot out there on accumulation strategies and how to accumulate, even some guidelines on how much to accumulate. But there is this kind of blank spot for retirees. Like once you've accumulated and you move into retirement, what should you be thinking about and what questions should you be asking?
And those are really the the topics we wanted to tackle with this paper. And this is what I love about this paper because I always think about this all the time, the point in time where you're in this accumulation mode and you're trying to kind of build up your portfolio and you're trying to build your wealth. And all of a sudden you get to the point in time where you need to kind of enjoy this portfolio and kind of utilize it as income.
Psychologically, that can be a difficult point in time to reach where then you kind of have to overcome, OK, now I have to draw this down and start spending this. So I love that you guys did this because I feel as though there's a lot of questions that have not been answered for a long period of time that you all have answered in this research paper.
And for all those listeners right now, the the paper will be linked up down the show notes below so that you can check that out as well. And everyone knows I'm a huge Vanguard fan here and that everybody you know who listens to this show for a long time knows we love everything that that you all put out. So upfront, the paper makes a pretty bold claim, kind of talking about the most important factor to a successful retirement is not how much you have saved, but how much you withdraw every single year.
Now, this has been something that has been a point of contention, I think over the last couple of years. But why did you lead with that? And what does the average person get wrong when they fixate on the balance instead? Yeah. So the reason we decided to focus on this and and we really did bring it front and center in the paper, right?
Like, this is one of the first things we say in the paper and we felt it was really important to get it out there right away because I do think this is one of the biggest mistakes that retirees make, right? As an, as an accumulator, typically you hear a lot of things around, hey, you need $1,000,000 to retire.
You need $2,000,000 to retire. You, you need $3,000,000 to retire, right? But a specific amount in your retirement account does not guarantee retirement success because it's all about what you want to do in retirement and how much you need to spend in retirement, right?
So like take for example someone who has a half million dollar portfolio and maybe they live pretty frugally. Maybe they have a lot of guaranteed income, so they need $10,000 a year from their portfolio to meet their retirement goals. Well, if you assume zero returns, right, that portfolio will last 50 years.
But if you have $1,000,000 and you're withdrawing $100,000 a year, it only lasts 10 years. So it's not how much you have because, you know, the smaller portfolio in the example I gave lasts five times as long as the $1,000,000 portfolio, which is twice as large.
So it's not about your balance, it's about how you're spending that down. And one of the things we say in the paper is we, we lay out four principles for retirement income, right? And we start with goals. Their goals cover the essentials, make your wealth last and, and, and simplify goals are the most important because that helps you define what do I need my money to do?
Where is my money coming from? And how much do I need from My Portfolio to support my retirement goals? And so setting those goals and and defining what your what your portfolio withdrawal rate needs to be, that is going to determine whether your retirement plan is successful or not.
And we wanted to get right out in front of that. That is one of the most important things that I think you get guys did up front is I think it's just really, really great where you put that in kind of how you're leading with that. Because the misconception for many people is, you know, the amount that you have on hand is all that you need to focus on. But instead you flip the script and showed all.
There's a lot of different variables involved in this. We got to make sure that we are nailing those down first. Now, one of the things that you talk through is, well, is the landing on, you know, the withdrawal rate and kind of thinking through, OK, what would support the retiree over the course of 30 years or more and how much should they be withdrawing?
Now, this has been something that has been debated over the course of the last couple of decades. I feel as though where we've seen, you know, Bill Bangin, the founder of the the creator of the 4% rule. And we've seen people come in like the Trinity study talking about the 4% rule and then people now saying, oh, actually you can withdraw a little more than 4%.
But your paper has some interesting statistics and it has some interesting ideals when it comes to, you know, the withdrawal rate, where you landed right around that 3 1/2 to 4% rate. That is what can support somebody for 30 years or more. For someone who grew up hearing something like the 4% rule, what is actually new or different about how you got into that range?
Look, the the 4% rule, as you said, it's been around for a long time. It's kind of classic. It's been debated on and off. But at the end of the day, it's, it's a heuristic, right? And, and time has proven it to be a pretty good heuristic, but we wanted to take a little a little bit different approach and we wanted to either come up with our own sustainable withdrawal rate or perhaps which we kind of did in this case reaffirm the 4% rule.
So what we did when we were doing our research and analysis for this paper was we took a number of persona and ran them through a forward-looking life cycle analysis. And some of the things that are a little bit different from what in what we did from, from the traditional 4% rule.
The traditional 4% rule is backward looking. It looks at previous, it looks at historical returns and said, well, you know, for the last 30 years, a 4% withdrawal rate was was acceptable. But we all know that, you know, past returns are no future or no guarantee of future returns and all of that.
So we wanted to take a forward-looking approach using Vanguard's capital markets model, our our, our proprietary capital markets model. And we ran a number of personas through our capital markets model with different assumptions.
And maybe most significantly, we used stochastic life expectancies when we were doing this, right. So in contrast to a lot of these other studies that have done where they say, hey, we're going to assume that everyone dies at age 8085 a hundred, right, We used stochastic life expectancy out to age 110.
And we looked at the results and looked to see like what is a withdrawal rate that is sustainable that takes into account life expectancy uncertainty. And where we landed was 3 1/2 to 4%, right?
And I'm, I'm familiar with some of the work you're talking about where they're saying, hey, maybe it's 4 1/2%, maybe it's 5%, Maybe the 4% rule is a little bit too conservative. And I think depending on your assumptions, that may be true, right? But based on our analysis using stochastic returns and stochastic life expectancies, this is kind of where we found the sweet spot to be.
And I love that you all stretch that out to give a little cushion on that 110 years because I think that's very important as we have seen, you know, just things progress over the course of the last couple of years. We don't know how long we're going to live and having that additional cushion is very, very helpful. I'm Mr. Conservative when it comes to some of these models and I definitely am for sure excited that you guys kind of did that because I think that's a very, very important metric to to look into.
Yeah. And, and and that does help, you know, we'll, we'll get to longevity here in a minute I believe. But you know that that also helps offset that longevity risk. Exactly. I think that's the big key because as we get, we see, you know, medicine progressing and people are living a little bit longer and we don't know what AI is going to bring in terms of like some of the, the stuff that could happen in medicine.
So there can be a lot of shifts over the course of the next couple years and many of us could be living longer. And I love that you have that in there there as that cushion. There's another number that jumped out at me, which I thought was fascinating, was reducing your withdrawal rate by just a half a percent can add up to five years to how long your money lasts within your portfolio.
Can you kind of walk listeners through why such a small change can have such a big impact on their money? Yeah. So look, one of the things we wanted to really stress in this paper was we know there are some people out there who are going to reach retirement and feel like, wow, I've really dropped the ball, like I am not ready to retire.
I haven't saved enough. Like, what is my retirement going to look like? And so one of the things we focused on in this paper was the fact that, look, if if you're getting ready to retire, there are a lot of things you can do that can help improve your retirement outcomes that don't require a whole lot of sacrifice.
And this reducing your spending rate by just half a percent is one of those things. And the reason this works really comes down to compounding, right? We talked about compounding as being like, you know, one of the one of the wonders of the investing world. And we usually think of that in terms of, hey, invest early and and receive that compounding.
Well, it ends up it works in retirement too, right? So if I cut my spending in retirement, especially if I do it early in retirement, let's say I'm withdrawing $45,000 a year on a $1 million portfolio and I cut my spending by half a percent.
So I cut it down to $40,000, right? That's $5000 a year that I am not spending, right? That is $5000 a year that I am effectively saving that I am earning returns on. And over a 30 year retirement that really adds up.
You know, you think about it, $5000 a year for 30 years, that's $150,000 before we even take into account any returns, right? That's almost four years of spending right there. You add returns on top of that over a 30 year time period and you get to five years, maybe even a little beyond depending on what your what your return assumptions are.
So by starting early, and this is one of the reasons we really encourage people go into retirement with a retirement plan. Know what your numbers are, know where your money's coming from, know what you're going to do. Because if you can start early, these little changes can make a huge difference over a 30 year retirement.
If you wait until you're already in crisis mode, then you're going to have to make a lot bigger cutbacks. It's such an important note because there are way too many people even now that just enter into retirement without that plan in place. And you got to have that plan to understand what you're going to be doing and know some of the risks even early on in retirement that we'll be talking about in this episode too, 'cause I think it's just, it's just so incredibly important to have that plan in place.
So I, I love that you guys are, are diving deeper into there and, and the big thing that that you guys were talking about is kind of looking at you make the case that longevity can be a bigger risk and it is going to be an increasingly bigger risk over the course of the, the next few decades. And for many people out there, if they don't plan for this longevity or if they don't plan that this is going to happen and they live longer than anticipated, this could be something that you know is is a bigger issue for your retirement plans.
So how should someone think about this when it comes to the risk of simply living longer over time? Yeah. So like, look, let's let's be clear, longevity is a good thing, right? People are living longer, they're living healthier lives, they're getting more out of their life.
These are all good things. But the problem it causes from a retirement planning standpoint is it means your portfolio, your retirement portfolio has to last for longer. And that's really where the longevity risk comes in, right? Like a good analogy is you're going on a car trip, you're going on a road trip and you have one tank of gas.
That's all you're allowed, right? And so as you're going down the road, maybe you run into some construction, you run into traffic, it slows you down. You find out you've got to climb a lot of hills. Well, that impacts how, how, how much gas you use, how quickly your gas tank is used up, right?
But if you're, if suddenly your trip gets extended by 50 or 100 miles, right, no matter how good the road is, no matter how smooth your trip, you're going to run out of gas before you reach your destination, right? And so in this, in this analogy, right, the road conditions are the market returns.
So you can have good market returns, you can have bad market returns. And yes, that's a risk and, and it impacts how long your money is going to last. But no matter how good the market conditions are, if you're not, if you haven't planned to live a longer time, you're going to run out of money anyway.
And that's why we say that longevity is actually the bigger risk. Not only because even in good market conditions, longevity can can create a failure of your retirement plan, but it's also one that people don't think about a whole lot. And when it comes to market conditions, I think this is a, a big thing that most people need to know.
We just did an entire episode actually recently on this podcast just talking about sequence of returns risk and, and how people just need to think about this and make sure they understand how this works and how to kind of plan for this. So can you kind of dive into sequence of returns risk and how it can kind of damage a retirement plan if you have some of these bad years early on and you don't have a plan in place on how you're going to withdraw or how you're going to think about some of this stuff?
Yeah, I actually listened to your episode on on sequence of returns risk and and, and I really enjoyed it. I think you and I agree on on a lot of things there. Yeah. Sequence of returns risk is just the risk that in the beginning, early years of your retirement, you hit a string of bad returns in the stock market, right?
And some of the things we hear for accumulators, and this is one of those places where the math works very different for accumulators than it does for retirees, right? If you're an accumulator, the order your returns come in doesn't make a whole lot of difference to you because you've got time for the market to recover.
And more importantly, you're not drawing down on your portfolio. When you retire and you hit a bad string of returns, you still have to make withdrawals from that portfolio. So you are reducing the balance even more quickly than the market is doing it for you.
So like if the market's down 30% and you have to withdraw 5% of your portfolio each year, you're down 35% that year, right? And when the market recovers you, you're still withdrawing 5%. If the market goes up 2020%, you're only up 15% and on a smaller asset base than you started with.
And, but especially if you get a string of bad years early on, this can really quickly erode your asset base and put your retirement plan in in real danger that can be really, really tough to recover from as a retiree.
You know, the best way people can offset that risk is by maintaining a reasonable asset allocation. At Vanguard, we are big proponents for retirement goals of glide paths that de risk over time, right?
So when you get to retirement, you have a balanced portfolio of equities and fixed income and, and the fixed income acts as ballast in the portfolio. It helps offset the volatility of those equities. So if you're 5050 and the equity market is down 20%, maybe your portfolio's only down 10.
It really cushions that blow. And so I think one of the most effective mitigating actions you can take for sequence of returns risk is to make sure you have a reasonable asset allocation. Absolutely. And I think that's one of the the most important things that people need to realize.
If you do not have that asset allocation that fits your risk tolerance in place upfront, it is one of those areas where we need to make sure that we are mitigating against some of those downturns, especially in those early years. Those early years are so incredibly important because you can see the impact on that portfolio. And especially when I look at people who, you know, we've talked about the retirement spending smile a couple of times in the in the past as well, where you can kind of see, OK, well, early on, people are spending a little more, maybe in their early years, they want to have some of those experiences.
They're enjoying their time, they finally get to retirement age and they have the ability to kind of enjoy this. And in the middle, you know, they're starting to spend a little less. You know, they've seen the sites, they've done some of the things that they want to do. And then as time goes on, well, Healthcare is going to be kicking in. And so those costs are going to rise again. But you can see when you are spending or drawing down earlier on, many people have that risk in place.
And so whatever the market conditions are, we just have to have a plan in place in order to make sure that we are looking at this the right way. Now, one of the big things that we think through too is, you know, the essentials and covering the essentials is something that a topic that you guys cover a lot in this paper as well.
And you frame Social Security as an annuity for that people already own, which I love. I love that framing. I think that's the way I kind of think about Social Security. And so for someone trying to decide when to claim, we know kind of, you know, the later you claim, it's kind of like a guaranteed 8% rate of return when you kind of push off a few different years.
What is the simplest way you think that people should consider thinking about this? And should they actually wait till 70? Should they actually, you know, consider claiming earlier? How should they actually think about Social Security? So look, I think Social Security is one of these things like a lot of of topics when it comes to retirement planning or financial planning in general, there's no one-size-fits-all answer, right?
When you are making your Social Security claiming decision, the main trade off you're making is less monthly income now potentially for longer, right? Or more monthly income later, potentially for a shorter period of time.
And the real question becomes, how long am I going? Do I think I'm going to live, right? So if you think you're going to live beyond your kind of normal life expectancy, then delaying can be really powerful, right? Because once you claim that once you get that bump for delayed claiming, that lasts for the rest of your life, no matter how long you live, right?
But the important thing to remember is that Social Security is about as actuarially fair as any kind of payout system gets, right? So what that means is if you live to your normal life expectancy, it doesn't matter whether you claim early or delay your lifetime benefits should be the same about right?
So there are a few things people should think about. Probably one of the most important is how long do you expect to live? What is your health like? What is your family history of longevity like? Do you expect to live long enough to break even on your claiming decision?
If you think you are if you're in poor health or have reason to think that you know you you may not make it to normal life expectancy, then you should probably think about claiming early. If you're healthy income from a a lineage of long lived people, then it probably makes sense to to delay claiming. The other factors that come into play here are do you need the money, right.
Some people retire with minimal assets. Maybe they were forced into retirement because of health reasons or or they just can't work anymore for whatever reason and they really need that money, that Social Security to, to help them pay the bills early on in retirement. That's fine.
That's a perfectly valid reason to claim early, right? Other people may not need that money as soon they've got plenty of savings and they can afford to live off those savings until age 70. For them, it probably makes more sense to delay. So you know, it, it really depends on what your financial and health situation is and what works best for you.
And, and I will say, like, look, we tried to make the, the framework and the decision points within the paper as simple as possible. We really wanted people to be able to use this on their own. But Social Security claiming can get really complicated. And this would be a good place for people to go and consult with an advisor to look over their their options and decide which approach is best for them.
Agreed. I think that's one of the the most important areas to kind of make sure that you know, you know where you are, where you stand and where you land, because for each person, it is very personal in terms of how you want to think about this. And it can get more and more complicated as you'll even see, you know, if you're married, that's another pain point where, you know, this can be a complicated scenario on who should claim first.
Should they start to take, you know, early? Should somebody else start to take later? And then you start to get into this scenario kind of how to think about this. And so even for married couples, you kind of describe a coordination of play where the spouses claim at different times. Can you explain kind of how that even works and why it can protect surviving spouses if you do this the right way?
Absolutely. So one of the most powerful Social Security claiming decisions is coordination of spousal benefits, right? And the reason for this is when one spouse dies, the other spouse gets a spousal benefit. And that spousal benefit is either equivalent to their own benefit or the deceased spouses benefit, whichever is greater.
So if you have a situation like many families do, where you have one spouse that is a higher earner and another one that hasn't earned as much during the career. Keeping in mind that Social Security benefits up to a point are directly tied to income during your working years, it can make a lot of sense for the higher earner to delay their claiming to age 70 to maximize their benefit.
And what happens then is when that higher earner passes the higher benefit that they have accrued by waiting until age 70, the surviving spouse can claim that much, much higher benefit and end up having a much higher Social Security benefit than they would if they had relied on their own earnings record and their own Social Security benefits, or if the higher earner had claimed at age 67 or 62 or some younger age.
So it's really about maximizing the survivor benefits. I love that. And I think for most people, just knowing how to do that the right way and knowing that this is the, the process I think is, is really, really important. So if you're thinking about this again, like we're talking about here, you know, it's really, it's really great to consult an advisor, especially when you're trying to think through, you know, finding, figuring out when to claim Social Security because I think it's a a very important and a very needed solution to what most people are trying to think through there.
And then complete. Completely agree. And Social Security claiming strategies tend to be one of the more complex retirement topics. So yeah, agree this is another place where an advisor could add a lot of value. And I can tell you, like most of you know, my, my, even my parents, for example, they, they're kind of in their, their late 60s now and most of their, their friends are either just retiring or recently retired.
That's the number one question they always ask me. They come to me and say, hey, when should I claim Social Security? I'm like, listen, I can't look at your situation. You have a doctor, an advisor about that, which is for sure a big, big question that comes up. Well, and, and it's complicated, you know, I mean, I do this for a living and I look at some of the Social Security rules and not only do I do do this for a living, but I'm an attorney by education and I look at some of these Social Security rules and I'm like, what for?
Sure it is. It is a whole different animal for sure, which it's it's one of those things for like your individual situation is very important. So I love. That. Absolutely. And so one of the things that that paper talks about as well is annuities. Now annuities with some of my audience has a bad reputation. And the reason why is because the fees, they kind of always talk about fees and what's going to come into play when they are thinking about annuities.
But I have, you know, read a lot of work from a lot of different people. And there are some very smart people who kind of claim, OK, well, annuities actually can make sense for certain people. They can make sense in certain situation. So when does something like an income annuity genuinely make sense, or when is it something that's just kind of wasted time or just the wrong tool for someone?
Yeah. So let's be clear. I mean, I completely agree with your statement that there's a lot of skepticism around annuities out there, right? They can be very expensive. In the past, there's no question that they have been missold and they've just gotten a really bad reputation in the industry.
That does not, however, mean that the right annuity for the right person cannot add a lot of value, right? And in our paper, we really focused specifically on fixed annuities. So we didn't talk about variable annuities, we didn't talk about indexed annuities, right?
We focused very specifically on fixed annuities and part of the reason we did that is in some ways fixed annuities are almost like the index fund of the of the annuity world, right? They tend to be fairly low fees. They're kind of boring.
They do one job, but they do it quite well, right? And so we decided to focus on on fixed annuities because they really fit the need that we were focused on in our paper, in the section on our paper uncovering the essentials. What we say is to the extent possible, you should really seek to cover your essential expenses.
Those are your basic living expenses, housing, food, transportation, health insurance premiums, right? The things that if you can't afford them, they are going to significantly erode your standard of living. These things should as much as possible be covered by guaranteed income.
So no matter how long you live, no matter what happens in the market, you know your basic living expenses are covered. So what are forms of, of, of guaranteed income? Well, we've talked about Social Security. Pensions are another form of guaranteed income, right?
But if you still have a gap between your guaranteed income and your essential expenses, this is where an annuity can come in and be really handy, right? Fixed annuities tend to be fairly inexpensive from a fee standpoint, and they provide you a guaranteed income for the rest of your life.
And what that does is along with other forms of guaranteed income, it puts a floor under your spending where you can say, no matter what happens, I'm going to have at least this much income that I know I can count on and pay bills with. And I think that's where a fixed annuity is really, really valuable, right.
So who should perhaps consider a fixed annuity? Anyone who has meaningful longevity risk. So if you, for instance, you look at your, you do your retirement plan and you have kind of a marginal withdrawal rate, maybe it's 5% or so.
You know, an annuity can come in really handy there because if you're, if you're unfortunate enough to run into bad markets and you have a slightly high withdrawal rate, you could end up exhausting your portfolio and an annuity can provide you that floor of consumption.
Also, if you're just worried about living a long time, an annuity might be appropriate for you, right? When they are not appropriate is when you have no meaningful longevity risk. So either you have a really large portfolio and or your portfolio spending needs are really low, like 1 to 2% of your portfolio where you can basically self insure that longevity risk.
An annuity might not not make sense in that in that case because there's really, you know, no longevity risk to protect against there. Another place would be if you really prioritize flexibility, right? One of the downsides of an annuity is once you pay that money to the annuity company, it's gone.
You're not getting it back, right? So if you really prioritize financial flexibility, then an annuity might not be right for you in that case either. So they're not for everyone. I think a couple of key things to remember is annuities are insurance products.
They are not investment products. And I, I think they should be looked at that way. You don't buy homeowners insurance or auto insurance because you think you're going to get a big payoff at, at the end of it, right? You buy it to protect you from catastrophe. And annuities are served the same purpose.
They are insurance against running out of money and I think viewed in that way they make a lot more sense than trying to trying to view them as investment products. I love that reframe because that's exactly what I was going to say is it's basically you are just ensuring that your income is going to be there, you know, during the long term if you are going to go this route.
And again, there's, there's pros and cons obviously to each side. But I think for some people it can make sense, especially when you keep those fees low and you look at it in a way that, you know, if you are buying your income and making sure that your income stays level and you're covering your expenses, that's what gives you Peace of Mind and that's what reduces your stress and anxiety around your retirement.
That may be a good move. Because, you know, even just the psychology side of this, removing that stress and anxiety out of the equation could be very helpful for some people. So looking into this, or at least just kind of, you know, talking to your advisor and kind of understanding, you know, the pros and cons of each of these options can be something that is great.
But again, like Garrett said, I think this is something it has been oversold. The wrong annuities have been sold to the wrong people, which is why they get that bad rap. But in reality, it just it's going to depend on each and every single. Yeah, and, and, and, and you said something that that I just want to kind of reiterate here and expand on a little bit.
You know, you were you were talking about like, hey, if you want that Peace of Mind that comes with having that insurance, right. I think that's a really important point because I think there are very few right and wrong decisions when it comes to financial planning, right? There are trade-offs involved with every decision.
And that's really what we look at are what are the trade-offs? And, and yes, we, we kind of say, hey, for the, for the kind of average person like this is probably the better trade off than this. But if buying that annuity, even if you don't really need it from like a strictly quantitative point of view, if buying that annuity gives you Peace of Mind and helps you sleep at night and you feel like, you know what, it was worth it because I feel so much better now that I've done this, then that's not a bad decision, right?
That's a good decision. I think a lot of times when we talk about financial planning and we talk about personal finance, we get really caught up on the quantitative piece. Like from a financial standpoint, what's the right answer? But we also have to keep in mind at the same time, money is emotional and sometimes, not always, but sometimes the emotional answer actually is the right answer.
But you've got to know what the what you're paying for that going into it. Exactly. I could not agree more because I, I believe, you know, money really comes down to kind of 90% your psychology or emotions, how you behave. And that is really where, you know, if you can remove some of that stress and anxiety of the equation that is using money as a tool to enjoy it.
And I think that is that is a huge piece of this whole equation that everybody should be considering as they start to think through some of this stuff. Now you guys found that the order that you pull money from accounts, I love this stat can cut lifetime tax bills by about 14%. So what is the default order that you recommend and why does it work?
And is it? Is there a default order or is this something that it just depends on each person again? So it does depend on each person. It depends on your goals. It depends on on your account mix and, and how much money you have and, and a lot of other factors, right. But what we found was about 80% of the time what we consider our default withdrawal order is the optimal withdrawal order for people.
And that is take from your taxable accounts first, your tax deferred accounts next and then leave your tax free accounts until last, right. And essentially the reason this works for most people is because that is the order from least tax efficient to most tax efficient, right?
You take it, you take a taxable account and each year you have to pay taxes on dividends, interest, realized capital gains. If you're holding funds, you may pay capital gains taxes on gains you didn't even realize because they were realized within the funds, right?
And all of these taxes that you have to pay as you go erode your after tax return. And really what my team looks at and what withdrawal order is trying to do is maximize your after tax returns. So all other things being equal, a taxable account is going to have the most tax drag and have the lowest after tax return.
So get that out of your portfolio first. Give your more tax efficient accounts more time to grow in a tax in a tax deferred or tax freeway. The next least tax efficient account is is a tax deferred account.
Now you don't get taxed as you go. All of your capital gains and interest and dividends, they're all reinvested. You don't get taxed until you withdraw them. But when you withdraw them, they're treated as ordinary income and you pay income tax on them. So more efficient than a taxable account, less efficient than a tax free account, a tax, a free account, a Roth, you know, you put the money in, it grows tax free.
You don't pay taxes along the way and everything you take out is tax free. Not only that, but it passes to your heirs tax free if you have something left. And so just by spending your money, getting that tax drag moved out of your portfolio as quickly as possible can save you a lot of money over your lifetime in in tax liabilities.
And many people listening right now maybe saying to themselves, OK, that's interesting, but I want them to just kind of paint a picture of exactly how much savings this is. So anybody who has more than say $1,000,000 in their portfolio, this could be up to A6 figure differential or decision just by making sure you understand this.
And This is why it's so important to go into retirement like we're talking about here with this financial plan in place, because once you have the plan in place, it is not, not just, you know, saving money upfront and understanding, you know where or when you're going to spend, but it's also just understanding the account order and understanding exactly what is going to happen here.
It is a six figure to even 7 figure decision depending on how big that portfolio is. So in reality, this is a huge, huge deal for many of us to understand. And so I think that is, that is wonderful information. And, and the research is so compelling. I, I highly encourage everybody to read that section because I think it's just so incredibly powerful.
And it, one of the cool things is you wrote that more than 80% of investors could benefit from Roth conversions. And I think this is something that I think is really, really interesting for a lot of people because sometimes the people are like, well, I thought Roth conversions were just for people who are making too much to contribute to a Roth IRA. But there are so many different strategies that you can have available when it comes to Roth conversions.
So is there a specific window in retirement when you think people should kind of think about this? Is it when they're coming up on RM DS? And is there a sweet spot to this on when they should look at those Roth conversions? Yeah. So for the vast majority of people, there is definitely a sweet spot to do Roth conversions, and that is in between the year you retire and stop receiving employment income and the year you turn 75 and have to take RMDS.
Right. Those years tend to be the lowest income years in a retiree's life because you know, you're not receiving employment income and getting taxed on that RM DS. Once you're forced to take those, those can be significant, especially if you've been a good saver and those are going to bump you up into higher tax brackets.
But that that kind of middle area between those two things for most people, they tend to be years where income is low and as a result, they're in lower tax brackets than they ever will be again in their life, right. And so it's important to remember that the way Roth conversions work is I take money out of my traditional account, I, I pay taxes on that withdrawal and I put it into my Roth account, right?
And so This is why low income is having low income is, is an important point is because the less income tax you can pay on that conversion, the more valuable that conversion is going to be. So do it during those years where you're in a low tax bracket and are paying low taxes and pay a lot of attention to how much you're converting and manage your tax brackets, right?
If you can do it in the 12% tax bracket, that's a bargain. If you bumps it up to the 22% tax bracket, depending on your tax situation, that can still be really beneficial, right? If you're going up to the 37% tax bracket to do a Roth conversion, you're probably not getting a whole lot of benefit out of doing that, right.
So there there is some planning that needs to be done there. We call it threshold planning. And again, this is one of those places where it can get really complicated and an advisor can really help with this. Absolutely, because if you do this in the wrong time frame of the wrong year, you could end up with a big tax bill that you did not anticipate.
And so for sure that's a a big deal is, is knowing what years are optimal to to make sure that you are doing this. The other thing that people need to keep in mind and this, this is a little bit of a mind, this is a little bit of a psychology shift for a lot of retirees, right? Is that like with everything in investing and financial planning, there is a trade off with Roth conversions, right?
And that is, I pay more taxes today, but I save on my lifetime taxes in the future. And I think this is one of the hardest hurdles for people to get over, right? It's like, why should I have to pay $30,000 in additional tax today when I don't have to?
And the answer is, well, because over the next 2025 years, it's going to save you $75,000 in taxes, right? It's not taxes today that retirees when they're making their retirement plan should really be focused. It's how many, how much am I going to have to pay in taxes over my lifetime?
Because that's really what impacts your wealth, your long term wealth. Exactly. Those are those are some of the things even even understanding that is just a huge, huge differential for for a lot of folks is, is knowing when to take those. And I love that you guys are covering that in here. The next one is dynamic spending.
Now this is a concept I love. Dynamic spending is something that, you know, I grew up all, you know, reading about the 4% rule and that was like the end all be all. We kind of started at that point in time, but now that dynamic spending is something that has been, you know, a little more popularized. I think it's a very interesting concept and something I absolutely love.
Can you kind of explain dynamic spending and how guardrails work and and how that works? Maybe in practice even? Sure. So dynamic spending, quite Simply put, is you adjust your spending based on market conditions. So when markets are doing well, you give yourself a little bit of a raise, you allow yourself to spend a little bit more of that year.
When markets are down, you cut back a little bit, right? And what this does is it does a couple of things. We'll get to the guardrails in a second, but assuming you have your guardrails set correctly, what it does is it gives you a little bit more freedom to spend in good market years, but you cap your the raise you give yourself to a fairly low level.
So if the market has a really strong year, you're banking most of those returns for future years, right? And then on the downside, you create a floor where you say in a bad year I am going to cut my spending by 2 1/2 percent.
And what that does is it takes some of the stress off of your portfolio in those bad years. You know, when we were talking about sequence of returns risk, we talked about the damage that can happen to your portfolio when you are taking withdrawals during a down market.
And while that is most impactful in the early years of retirement, it's still, it can, it can still have an impact later on as well, right. So the idea with lowering your spending in bad years is to take some of that stress off of your portfolio during those bad years and give it more, leave more assets in the portfolio to recover later on.
So the way the guardrails would work, we typically recommend that 5% raise and 2 1/2% cut are are good guardrails to start with. If the market is up, you give yourself a raise equal to the increase in the market up to your ceiling.
So if it's a 2, if the market's up 2%, you give yourself a 2% raise. If the market's up 10%, you give yourself a 5% raise and you bank that other 5% for the future, right? If the market's down 1%, give yourself a 1%, cut your spending by 1%.
If it's down 10%, cut your spending by 2 1/2. Right now, the reason we we say that you should be pretty conservative with that floor number and how much you cut your spending is because while, while it's a good idea to cut spending during bad years, you don't want to cut yourself too short, right?
You want to make sure that you can cover all of your necessary expenses, maybe not go out to dinner quite as often or or go on that big European trip that you were planning, but, you know, still have some fun in your life. And so 2 1/2 percent is a number by which most people can cut their spending and not really feel too badly about it, right?
But it still helps preserve that portfolio value, especially if during the good years you're banking extra money. And what we found is that by doing this, by being just a little bit flexible in your spending, it can significantly increase the longevity of a portfolio and is really effective at at at avoiding potential large cuts in your spending later on in your retirement.
I think it's so important to note and I think I love that you guys do have that kind of cap on the reduction of spending because human psychology, as we just know, it's just it's just kind of harder to go backwards sometimes. And so making sure that we kind of have a balanced approach to that I think is really important. I've just noticed every single person that we coach or talk to is a, a lot of times they just have a difficult time kind of cutting back too far.
And so when you have this balance approach like that, I think that's much more helpful for most people. I completely agree, right. Like if I came to you and I said, Andrew, the markets are bad this year, I need you to cut your spending next year by 15%. Your reaction to probably like how am I supposed to do that, right?
Like, I don't even know where to start, but if I came to you and I said, Andrew, you need to cut your spending by 2 1/2% this year, you know, that's something that for for most people, it could be, oh, 2 1/2 percent. Well, yeah, yeah. OK. I, I, I I can probably do that, right. Like, that's not that much.
So yeah. Exactly it's it's that that one big thing that I think that is is so helpful overall. That's where I think most people worry about the guard rails is like, well, I thought to cut way, way back, but instead, you know, you guys have this great parameter around that that I absolutely love. And this all comes down to human psychology.
I mean, part of this is the the human side of kind of what we've been talking about here. And you all have a whole section in the paper about behavioral risk. And I think there's a lot of emotional mistakes that people can make when it comes to retirement. Is there any emotional mistake that you have seen many retirees make that could be either detrimental to their finances and how do they kind of build a plan to make sure they kind of separate some of their emotions from some of the things that they should be doing?
Yeah. So you know, like, look, I think taking, I think taking human emotion into account when you're doing financial planning is really, really important, right. Like I've said before that I can have quantitatively the perfect plan, right? And if I present those recommendations to to an investor and they look at it and they're like, there's no way, then that plan adds absolutely no value for that client, right.
So deviating from the quantitatively perfect to incorporate emotion and just investor psychology to get it to the point where it's like, well, maybe it's not absolutely perfect, but it's something they'll implement. There's a ton of value in doing that and I think that's really important to keep in mind.
As for your question about the biggest mistake that we've see people make, I think it's really just abandoning their plan for for whatever reason, right? Maybe it's that there's a big market drop and they got emotional and pulled their money out. Maybe it's that, you know, they decided that instead of staying in the in the home they had when they retired, they want to move across, they want to move to Florida or they want to move to Arizona and, and kind of start over, right?
Just abandoning their plan and moving forward without a plan, right? So they don't know how this is going to impact them. They don't know, they don't know what their what their costs are. They don't know how this is going.
They they haven't re established their goals. Like what is their purpose in doing this? And what does that mean for them? And so they they abandoned their plan and just kind of wing it. And that's not a plan that's relying on luck. And a lot of times that doesn't work out real well for people.
Now that's not to say that plans don't and shouldn't change, right? One of the things that we talked about in the paper is like, hey, you need to have your goals, you need to set priorities, but be aware of those priorities. They will change over time, right? If, if you have, you are not going to have the same priorities 20 years from now that you have today.
And that's OK, right? Like we expect priorities and and goals to change over time. You just need to adjust your plan with them, right? So the plan, once you make it, is not set in stone. It is, it is a living breathing document that you should update on a regular basis.
And if your priorities change, change your plan and incorporate those changes into your plans to make sure that you remain on track. I think the biggest mistake that we see people make is not going through that process of updating and changing their plan to reflect their their changing priorities.
So just abandoning, abandoning their plan all together and proceeding without a plan at all. I love that and I, I could not agree more. And, and even for folks who are listening right now, if you're in your 30s or 40s, I'm even a big proponent of them starting to think about their plan now and making those adjustments even as life progresses in the early years.
It's kind of like looking at your retirement number and looking at some of your plans that you have in place and just making those adjustments as you get closer and closer to retirement age. Because once you get 5 years out, you got to make sure that you have that plan security and you have thought through some of that plan. And then it's dynamic. You're, you have the ability to change it and make adjustments, but you just have to know what the implications are going to be if you do some of that.
So Gary, if someone is, you know, five years out from retirement and only changes one thing from this conversation, what should it be? Or is there just a slew of things that they should consider and it just depends on each situation? No, look, I'm going to go back to the first thing we talked about, right, And that is stop focusing on your balance.
Your balance is not what determines directly is not what determines your the success of your retirement plan. Start thinking about what do I want my retirement to look like? What are my other sources of income in retirement going to be?
How much income do I need to live the kind of life I want to in retirement and really start to focus in on that, that portfolio withdrawal number, and use that as a checkpoint to see if your retirement plan is realistic or not.
And if it's not, what changes you can make to achieve the kind of retirement you really want? And what I love is that it, the base the paper talks about, like what you just said, is that it's it's about turning your savings the life that you actually want. It's about kind of figuring out, you know, what your dollars need to do and using money as a tool to get the life that you actually want.
After doing all this modeling and after doing all this math, is there anything that surprised you most about what people actually want or what makes them feel secure in retirement? You know, I, I think, I think the biggest thing is, is the goals piece, right? You know, being able to sit down and say, like, this is my vision for retirement and this is what I need to make to bring that retirement into reality really simplifies the retirement planning process.
You know, people view retirement planning as being really, really complicated. And it is like I, I don't want to give people the impression that like, oh, this is really easy. Anyone can do it, right? Like it's really complicated. But you know, retirement planning is, is like taking a trip, right?
If you don't know what your destination is, it's really difficult to plan for that trip. And your goal is really your destination. So that's where you start. Like this is where I want to get to. And if you if you figure out what your destination is, then it's, it's not easy, but it's a lot easier to fit all the other pieces into place.
The last thing you want to do is pack a bathing suit on your trip to Alaska. So I love that analogy. I think that's absolutely perfect. Unless you want to join the Polar Bear Club. Exactly. I should go to cold plunge. Exactly. So that's that's exactly right. Well, Garrett, thank you so much for coming on here. This has been absolutely phenomenal.
Where can people learn more about you, what you have going on and everything else, all the Vanguard research you all are doing? Yeah. So go to vanguard.com and click on the Resources and Education tab and you can find all of our articles and thought leadership there. Wonderful. We will link that up down below in the show notes.
Again, thank you so much for being on here. This was a wonderful conversation. Thanks Andrew, I've really enjoyed it.
Andrew is positive, engaging, and straightforward. As someone who saw little light at the end of the tunnel, due to poor saving/spending habits, I believed I would be entirely too dependent on Social Security. Andrew shows how it’s possible to secure financial freedom, even if you’ve wasted the opportunities presented in your youth. Listened daily on drives too and from work and got through 93 episodes in theee weeks.
This podcast has been exactly what I have been looking for. Not only does it solidify some of my current practices but helps me to understand the why and the ins-and-outs to what does work and what doesn’t work! Easy to listen to and Andrew does a great job and putting everything in context that is applicable to everyone.
Excellent content, practical, straight to the point, easy to follow and easy to apply! Andrew takes the confusion, complexity and fear as a result (often the biggest deterrent for most folks) out of investing and overall money matters in general, and provides valuable advice that anyone can follow and put into practice. Exactly what I’ve been looking for for quite some time and so happy that I came across this podcast. Thank you, Andrew!
Absolutely a must listen for anyone at any age. A+ work.
Absolutely love listening to this guy! He has taken all of my thoughts and questions I’ve ever had about budgeting, investing, and wealth building and slapped onto this podcast! Can’t thank him enough for what I’ve learned!
I discovered your podcast a few weeks ago and wanted I am learning SO MUCH! Finance is an area of my life that I’ve always overlooked and this year I am determined to make progress! I am so grateful for this podcast and wish there was something like this 18 years ago! Andrew’s work is life changing and he makes the topic fun!
You know there’s power when you invest your money, but you don’t know where to start. Your journey starts here…
Our website address is: https://mastermoney.co.
When visitors leave comments on the site we collect the data shown in the comments form, and also the visitor’s IP address and browser user agent string to help spam detection.
An anonymized string created from your email address (also called a hash) may be provided to the Gravatar service to see if you are using it. The Gravatar service privacy policy is available here: https://automattic.com/privacy/. After approval of your comment, your profile picture is visible to the public in the context of your comment.
If you leave a comment on our site you may opt-in to saving your name, email address and website in cookies. These are for your convenience so that you do not have to fill in your details again when you leave another comment. These cookies will last for one year.
If you visit our login page, we will set a temporary cookie to determine if your browser accepts cookies. This cookie contains no personal data and is discarded when you close your browser.
When you log in, we will also set up several cookies to save your login information and your screen display choices. Login cookies last for two days, and screen options cookies last for a year. If you select “Remember Me”, your login will persist for two weeks. If you log out of your account, the login cookies will be removed.
If you edit or publish an article, an additional cookie will be saved in your browser. This cookie includes no personal data and simply indicates the post ID of the article you just edited. It expires after 1 day.
Articles on this site may include embedded content (e.g. videos, images, articles, etc.). Embedded content from other websites behaves in the exact same way as if the visitor has visited the other website.
These websites may collect data about you, use cookies, embed additional third-party tracking, and monitor your interaction with that embedded content, including tracking your interaction with the embedded content if you have an account and are logged in to that website.
If you request a password reset, your IP address will be included in the reset email.
If you leave a comment, the comment and its metadata are retained indefinitely. This is so we can recognize and approve any follow-up comments automatically instead of holding them in a moderation queue.
For users that register on our website (if any), we also store the personal information they provide in their user profile. All users can see, edit, or delete their personal information at any time (except they cannot change their username). Website administrators can also see and edit that information.
If you have an account on this site, or have left comments, you can request to receive an exported file of the personal data we hold about you, including any data you have provided to us. You can also request that we erase any personal data we hold about you. This does not include any data we are obliged to keep for administrative, legal, or security purposes.
Visitor comments may be checked through an automated spam detection service.