Transcript:
On this episode of the Personal Finance Podcast, how to pursue financial independence and still enjoy your life.
Ooh, what's up everybody? And welcome to the Personal Finance Podcast. I'm your host, Andrew, founder of MasterMoney.co. And today on the Personal Finance Podcast, we're gonna be talking about how to pursue financial independence and still enjoy your life. If you guys have any questions, make sure you join the Master Money newsletter by going to mastermoney.co/newsletter.
And don't forget to follow us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or whatever your favorite podcast player is. And if you wanna help out the show, consider leaving a five star rating and review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast player. Now on today's episode, I'm gonna be talking with Justin Peters.
Now Justin is the host of the FiMinded Podcast, a podcast all about how to achieve financial independence without going to extremes. And if you've ever felt as though being on the path to financial independence means that you have to feel deprivation or you have to be deprived, this episode is for you.
Now, Justin has spent years talking to people who have reached financial independence, but the one thing that he noticed that a lot of people went through was that they didn't know how to spend their money. So he developed a framework that helps you spend intentionally, and I think this is such a cool way to think about how to make sure you're spending your dollars on your values.
And so today we're gonna be talking about how Justin thinks about spending money, some of the mistakes he made in the past when it comes to financial independence, and we're gonna be talking through how he manages his money, how he thinks about spending money, and some of the things that he does in his relationship as well to help him and his wife get on the same page.
This is one of those episodes that is definitely less about the math and more about the mindset, which is what I absolutely love about this, and you're gonna really, really enjoy this one. So I am so excited to introduce Justin Peters back to the Personal Finance Podcast So Justin, welcome back to the Personal Finance Podcast.
Andrew, it's a pleasure, man. I'm excited for round two. Me too. We're gonna have some fun conversations here about financial independence, and I know for all the listeners right now, your favorite topic that we talk about on this show is financial independence. Every single time we talk about, you know, trying to pursue financial independence, kind of the messy middle that a lot of people fall into or just kind of thinking about this process, those are some of our most popular, popular episodes.
So I'm really, really excited for this and excited to dive deeper into this. Now, I wanna kinda talk through this with you 'cause I think you're a master at this, is kinda figuring out how to enjoy your life while you're on the path to financial independence. And you've developed these systems that I think are just awesome when it comes to figuring out what your values are and figuring out, you know, how you want to approach financial independence, but also be able to, you know, have some fun, do some things that are actually enjoyable.
So can you talk about why it's so important when you're on the path to financial independence to actually enjoy your life a little bit here? Well, I appreciate you calling me a master at this because I, I didn't feel like a master, uh, while I was going through the, the front half of this journey. But a couple things come to mind when you ask me that question.
First of all, tomorrow's not guaranteed. Uh, so you, you should be enjoying today just as much as your, you're setting your future self up. Uh, and then second, I, I do think financial independence, especially for most people, uh, it's gotta take some time. You know, we're talking about decades, um, that you're gonna be spending.
So if you're not enjoying that time, ultimately you're either gonna burn out and probably take two steps back and/or, uh, you're gonna resent, uh, the, the whole process, the whole journey when you get to the finish line. So I'm a big proponent in, uh, enjoying the moment while also, like I said, taking care of your future self.
For sure. And I think, you know... I think about my 20s for example, and in my 20s I was just super frugal. And it was this timeframe where I was just getting my money together. I was trying to dig myself out of a paycheck to paycheck situation. And all of a sudden I went from someone who was spending some money to having this scarcity mindset where I just did not know, you know, what to do with my next dollar.
And every single time I started to think about spending money, I even remember feeling as though, like, ah, it would just stress me out. It would cause me distress and anxiety. Uh, and I did not know what my values were whatsoever. And, and so early on in my financial independence journey, and even all the way to my late 20s, I just remember, like, foregoing things that I wish I would not have done.
And this was a learning experience for me. I know now, like, for a lot of people, I get to help a lot of people in these situations try to figure out, you know, how to find what their values are. But do you feel as though, you know, early on in your financial independence journey you kinda struggled with something similar to that?
And was this... You know, was your relationship with money broken? Or was this something that you felt as though you had to kind of work on over time? It's such an interesting question that you ask that 'cause on one hand, like, I don't feel like my relationship with money was broken. You know, I actually loved learning about money.
I liked making money. Uh, I liked saving and investing. But then on the other hand, there were pieces of my relationship with money that were totally broken, spending probably being the most obvious. It sounds like, uh, similar to you as well. I mean, I grew up in a household where, uh, saving, investing, earning money was praised, but then spending money, even spending money on things that were meaningful and valuable, was not something that was praised.
So I do think I, I had a little bit of a, a broken relationship, especially with spending money. But come on, what personal finance content creator did not have some kind of broken relationship with money at some point in time? So yes, uh, I had to go through all the same, uh, trials and tribulations that you're illustrating in your response as well.
Did you ever go through, like, the Mr. Money Mustache phase where you kind of l- You know, I... So for me specifically, like I, what, what I call that is, like, I read Mr. Money Mustache's blog, and I would go through, like, every single article, and I'd be like, "Okay, I'm gonna bike to work." And I was so excited to, like, do this.
My wife's like, "Well, there's a, you know, this is a, an eight-lane highway that you're gonna be biking to work. I don't think you're gonna be biking to work while you're going to, to work the..." And so, like, there was just all these different things that I was thinking through where I was like, "Okay, I wanna just make sure I'm spending, you know, less than $30,000 per year.
I wanna make sure that I'm just not... There's no waste whatsoever. I'm optimizing everything. I'm doing my own work and, you know, working on my own house even though I'm a terrible handy person." Uh, and just all these different things that I was kinda trying to figure out. Did you ever kind of go through that early on, or were you just kind of, "Hey, I got this set up, but I just didn't have my values or spending set up correctly yet"?
Oof. No. I wore the, the badge of honor of how little I could spend, you know? I was, I was always proud to be the, the frugalest of my friend group. And to some degree, that, that, that was helpful and, uh, and, you know, it's, it's nice to, to be cutting out some of the things that honestly didn't really bring me a lot of joy, but so many places it was a struggle.
I remember, uh, a little bit because of circumstances, I was living in San Diego, and I was just so strapped for cash. I, I was like... I switched jobs, that... I took a pay cut. I was living off, like, $50,000 in San Diego. Uh, you know, my house was, like, eating up, like, half of that. So yeah, I found myself doing, like, really dumb things like walking pretty much everywhere I could.
Uh, really, like, oh man, grocery shopping would take three times as long as it needed to be because I'd have to, like, price check the per ounce for, like, everything that I bought. I'm like, "Why am I doing this?" Uh, I, I like that I was being prudent with financial decisions, but I, I think I took it just a little bit too far.
And, and honestly, looking back and reflecting on that period of my life, I realized I would trim off the last 10% of the optimization, and I'd probably get 100% life satisfaction back from it. I love that. I think thinking through this and, and kind of figuring out some of the decisions that you make because it did for, for me create decision fatigue.
The same exact thing, like when you went to the grocery store. You're just trying to optimize for every single purchase, even if it's 25 cents. And I'm sitting here, like, trying to think through this. And I remember getting to the end of the day, and I was just, like, mentally exhausted from my own doing.
Like, I was just going over, like, every single purchase and every single price change and every single thing, and I would... It would take me forever to even buy anything which- Yep ... in some circumstances is awesome. But then in some circumstances, it was just one of those things that I was just overly frugal.
It didn't make sense. You know, get your mental capacity back so you can actually put it towards things that actually bring more value. So you developed this kind of system or these, these four spending principles that kind of helped you when it came to, you know, being able to spend on things that you actually value.
And so can you kind of talk about these spending principles, how they came about, and some of the things that you did to, to put them into place? Yeah, you teed this up great because the exact situation that you were talking about with that decision fatigue was the exact situation I was in. I was in this crux where I was about halfway through my financial independence journey, and I still wanted to be prudent and fin- financially responsible, but I wanted to, um, loosen the reins a little bit, and I just couldn't allow myself to do that.
Like, this decision fatigue on every spending decision was exhausting me. Um, so one day I... You know, it was the end of the year, I think probably four or five years ago. It was at end of a year and I was thinking through, "Okay, this next year, what do I, like what do I wanna spend on? Like, what, what can I do here?"
And I came up with a list of four rules. I didn't have names for them at the time, uh, but I slapped names on them just to help articulate them a little bit better. And then eventually the rules turned into principles, like kind of guiding lights instead of like hard and fast rules. Um, so I have four that I really love to follow and I still practice today.
One is a, a fun fund. This is just taking a portion of the money, uh, uh, take, taking a portion of my money and it has one job, and that is just enjoyment. Like, I have to spend this portion of money on something that would just bring me a lot of joy. Uh, so how I did this was if I made $5,000 that month and I spent $4,000, I'd have $1,000 at the end of the month left in my checking account.
What I'd normally do is just take that $1,000 and invest it in, uh, an IRA or a brokerage account or whatever, wherever I was going. And I implemented the fun fund that year, and I had to take 10% of that 1,000 now and set it into a different account, and that account could only be spent on, like I said, fun things.
Um, so that was the fun fund and that helped a lot. It just like alleviated a lot of like, "Ooh, I kinda want that, but ugh, I shouldn't be buying that. Well, how much money do I have in my fun fund? Oh, cool, I have some money in there. I'll go ahead and buy it." So that was, uh, principle number one. Principle number two is the oops budget.
This is like a no questions asked buffer so that when something unplanned, unexpected that was money related happened I had some money set aside that I could just go ahead and deploy that, to that situation because it was often, like, a already stressful moment. And what was happening with my money was I would run i- I'd have an accident.
Um, you know, maybe I cracked my phone and I gotta buy a new phone. And you know what happens when you break your phone. Like, y- that is a problem that you have to deal with right then and there. Yeah. And I would layer on top of this, like, financial stress too. Like, "Oh my gosh, now I just wasted, like, $1,000 and I gotta, like, go buy a new phone.
What are you doing, Justin?" So I came up with this oop- oops budget. It was $1,000 sinking fund that I set up. Now it's a little bit more fictitious. I just know in the back of my head that I have $1,000 for no questions asked, uh, type situations. And when a situation comes like this, I'll be like, "Ugh, that's a bummer, but I got my oops budget.
Go ahead, take care of the situation and move on." Uh, so that's been great. Uh, spending principle number three is the guilt-free spending categories. A lot of people have, uh, similar ideas to this too. Ramit Sethi was the one I, I really stole this from. Uh, I love the How to Money guys too, and they talk about their craft beer equivalent.
Um, very similar. Like, every year I pick one or two ca- categories in my budget that gives me, like, an outsized happiness to spend on. Um, and the goal isn't to underspend in that category. Actually, I think underspending would be a signal that I failed at this. I should be spending more than I really set out to spend on some of these categories.
So for me this year, uh, I have two things. That's relationship and health. If it's a, you know, friend ask if I wanna go grab dinner, uh, and it's kind of a no questions thing, I wanna go grab dinner with him, or it's health related. I just ran a really big trail race about a month ago. It cost me way too much money to buy the ticket, uh, the entra- entrance fee, the hotel for all of that.
It was like $1,500 for me to go and run. And I'm like, you know what, Justin? That was an investment in my health. Um, so this year those are my two categories, and I'm not feeling guilty about spending on those categories Uh, and then the very last one was one, um, that I think has really gotta get at the heart of this conversation today, and that's my moments that matter list.
Um, you were talking about some regrets on spending, and I don't... You know, looking back at my 20s and, you know, I was hyper frugal, but I don't regret most of that frugality. But there was one moment that I really regret. Um, a friend invited me to his wedding, and it was an out-of-state wedding. It was in a high cost of living, uh, city, and I remember going back and forth about attending, and I ended up declining.
And the reason I declined is was it was gonna cost me, like, 1,000 to $1,500 to go there. And I regretted it almost immediately as soon as I decided, as soon as I put in that no on the RSV- RSVP. And people ask me this question like, "Do you ever regret not, not spending on things?" And that is the w- only thing that really comes to mind on me.
So with that in mind, I came up... You know, on that day I was coming up with these principles. I made the moments that matter list, and these are a list of life events or experiences where it's just pre-decided that money won't have an outsized influence on that decision. There... I do think there are a lot of decisions that money should be a one, two, or three factor.
Like, I don't wanna overbuy a home and then be stuck in this, this mortgage cycle or buy a fancy car that I don't need. Um, but there are a couple of situations or experiences where I want money to fall down from a one, two, or three slot on the factor list down to, like, nine or 10. Um, so of, of that, weddings is on that list.
If someone invites me to a wedding, sure, I can say no if I just, like, don't wanna attend the wedding, it's not someone I'm super close to, but I don't want money to be the reason why I say no. Um, and then another one that I put on my, my list this year was visiting my parents. Um, I'm recognizing that I- I'm s- I'm having more and more limited time with my parents.
They're aging, and any time, no questions asked, if they say, "Hey, Justin, I'd love to go to a, a Cardinals baseball game. Like, you wanna come back to St. Louis sometime?" Buy the ticket. I don't care if the flight home is $150 or $500, I'm gonna find my way back home so I can spend some time with them I love that, and I think these are just so incredibly valuable for people to think through and th- people to have on hand.
So I have some questions on these because I think these are, these are gonna be really cool. So when it comes to... So I have something similar on the first one, which I have-- I call it the blow fund, but, uh, it's, it's a fund where basically I started this because my wife and I, when we first started kind of building wealth and kind of working through our personal finances, we couldn't figure out like how to just kind of put money in place where we could just blow it on anything and no questions asked, be able to kind of manage money together.
And so I, I realized pretty early on that we were just gonna separate these two places, and we can just spend that, you know, within that given month and just spend it on something that we really want. Like even if it's frivolous or something stupid, um, we can go and buy those things, and there's no questions asked there.
So is that kind of how yours works too, where it's like stuff you're actively trying to spend those dollars to kind of help you kind of enjoy life more or just kind of get more value out of, out of certain things in life? Or is it something that you are a little bit more cautious about spending, but you wanna spend it on those things that you have been kind of waiting to, to spend money on?
Uh, probably the first definition. Okay. It, it really is. I think my biggest struggle when it comes to money is just, like, buying things that would bring me joy or improve my life. I've moved through a couple of these things with, like, the guilt-free spending and the moments that matter. Like, I know the big things, um, but it's some of the little things that, like, the everyday happiness, uh, that I, I want this fund to really optimize for.
So right now I'm, like, really back into '90s nostalgia. I was a kid of the '90s, born in '93, and I love Pokémon, and I'm, like, reinvesting and getting my Pokémon card collection back. Uh, so a lot of what's coming out of my fun fund right now is just buying Pokémon cards, to be honest. I love it. Shiny cardboard.
Yeah, exactly. Exactly. I have a... My son got really into, um, like, sports cards recently. Mm-hmm. So we started to, like, send them to PSA to start grading stuff, and started to, like, open packs. And we opened packs, and I got really, I got really good at, like, figuring out which ones I could... Just to... Not to go too detailed for the audience here, but I built, like, this whole algorithm inside of Claude that told me which cards would have the highest chance to, to get a PSA 10 or a g- gem mint.
And so we started to send cards in. We came back with, like, thousands of dollars worth of PSA 10s because Claude figured out exactly which ones were worth grading. That's cool. So it was, like, actually pretty fun. So that's a whole separate conversation, but- We should, we should offline that and talk about that at- We should
'cause I'm so interested in that. 'Cause it was, it was a really cool thing. So, uh, yeah, we'll, we'll chat about that. But that is, like, a fun optimization. I think that's a great example because it's one of those things where I get into, like, a bunch of different little hobbies all the time. And I'm like, "Well, where am I gonna pull th- like, am I gonna pull this money from, you know, this category or where else?"
But I think that's perfect for exactly what you're talking about there. And then when you have kind of your, your oops fund, I have something similar. I call it, like, stuff I forgot to budget for. Mm. But typically my... But what it really is, is, like, a spot where, like, if there's an emergency that's a quick emergency and I don't wanna pull from my, you know, giant emergency fund that I have on hand, you know, I have these different categories in place that kinda help me with that.
Is that kind of what this is too? It's kind of like a buffer in between your emergency fund- Yes ... or is it part of your emergency fund? Yeah, it's definitely a buffer. Uh, actually, e- early on in the first couple of years I did this, I, I did have a totally separate sinking fund for this where I'd, uh, every single month I'd put, let's call it, like, $200 into this fund.
Um, so I'd come out with about $2,400 at the end of the year that when accidents come up, the things I didn't budget for, uh, et cetera, like, I would just pull out of that sinking fund. Now, like I said, it's a little bit more mental. Like, I ended up moving that money back into my general emergency fund. It's just sitting in there honestly just because of simplification, which might be something we talk about later in this conversation.
Um, and I just know mentally, like, "Hey, Justin, don't worry about the things that are, like, under $2,000 that you can't control. Don't beat yourself up for it again. Just go ahead and pay, uh, pay for it." So now it's way more psychological. Uh, it used to be a little bit more mechanical back in the day. I love that.
And then the guilt-free spending I think is for a lot of people, they, they understand that. It's kind of like the bigger ticket stuff that you're thinking through and, and kind of, you know, this is the stuff that I want. This is the stuff I want to be able to spend money on, and these are some of the i- you know, the, the areas that I wanna spend more on, whether it's, you know, being able to, you know, take a vacation or a trip or whatever else it is.
You know, stay in a fancy hotel, you know, take a first-class flight. There's all kinds of different stuff that you can kind of put into this category, I'm sure. Or if you want to get, you know, an amazing, you know, road bike, or if you want to be able to kinda do some cool things. That's kind of what that category is for, some of the bigger stuff potentially, right?
For sure. I find myself, if I'm gonna be hypervigilant on 10 of my budget categories and really make sure that I'm prudent and I'm spending well in those, that allowing myself one or two budgets for flexibility and freedom because I know it's bringing me some kind of outsized joy and happiness, then I think that's a pretty good trade-off.
I'd rather crush five or six, uh, categories and then really enjoy one or two things that I know is gonna bring me enjoyment. For sure. And I think that's, that's so important for everyone to have, and I think for many people listening, if you don't have something like that, it's worth going through this exercise and kind of thinking through what you truly value and identifying those values and where you're gonna put that money.
And the last one I absolutely love. This kind of reminds me of a little bit of, like, we had Sahil Bloom on the show, and he was talking through kind of the, the five different areas of wealth. And one of the areas he was talking about was, like, th- this time that you have, and you only have a limited time left with your loved ones, and some of it is aging parents, just like you're talking about.
Some of this is like, I always think about it with my kids where they say, you know, your kids are gonna be under your roof for a very small period of time. It's like that 18 years is, like, 90% of the time that you're gonna spend with them. And I always think about that, like, you know, even right now, I have a, an 8-year-old, a 5-year-old, and a one-and-a-half-year-old, and, like, it...
The time that I'm spending with them right now is gonna be one of those things where I'm gonna be 90 years old, kind of not being able you know, in a, a situation where I'm looking back on life, and this is where I'm gonna wanna come back to. This is the point in time where I'm gonna wanna spend a lot more time.
And I think being able to make decisions where you can spend time with family members, like aging parents. My parents are getting older, too, like, where they're, you know, g- approaching 70 now, and You know, you're gonna wanna get that time back, and having to make that decision or not being able to spend time with him because of money is not what you wanna be doing.
And I think same thing with your wedding example is a perfect example of, like, spending valuable time with, with friends or being able to be with friends on, on big moments like that I think is so incredibly valuable. So how did you come up with this, and how do you kind of think about what should go in that category?
It was honestly just a reflection of 10 years in my 20s and being like, "What did I really regret from it?" And, like, it never did, like, upgrading my car or buying more better clothes or any of that stuff really come to mind. It was really just, like, these one or two experiences that, that, that I'm like, "Ooh, that, that's what it is."
Um, and like I said, it's... The goal of this wasn't necessarily to alleviate, uh, spending entirely in these categories, but really just deprioritize it the, as most I can. And I don't know, for some reason, my brain just works like that. Like, I have to, like- Yeah ... give myself the permission to, to say, "Hey, this is a, a spending category that's in your moments that matter list, Justin.
Like, d- just press the button. Like, you're not gonna regret spending an extra $100 on the flight whenever you really gotta look back and enjoy the four days, five days that you spent with mom and dad and did these certain things." Um, so yeah, it was, it was a combination of reflecting back on regrets that I had and then really kind of looking at my expenses and being like, "What are the things that push come to shove, I would still wanna spend my money on?"
And, and that's kind of what made this list. Do you think there's kind of a fine line for a lot of people pursuing financial independence between kind of how they're thinking about this, where there's people who are disciplined, and we always obviously have to be disciplined when it comes to spending.
Otherwise, if you just spend freely without thinking about it ever, uh, it could be one of those things that gets out of control. But is there a fine line between kind of discipline and deprivation for a lot of folks out there? Hmm. And, and kinda how do you think about that? Oh, that's a really good question, and it's something I spend a lot of time on, and I think it's something that the financial independence community honestly should be doing a little bit more work on.
Between discipline and deprivation, if we're talking in terms of spending, I think it really comes down to not now versus I'm not allowed to. So not now being like that's the discipline. It's like you know, um, I'd love to spend this $200, but I'm putting that towards another goal. Like I'll... I'm gonna do that eventually, uh, but I have a different priority right now.
Versus deprivation could be like, I could afford to make this $200 purchase, um, but I shouldn't be spending money on something like this. Uh, you know, that's where I kind of see a lot of the, the difference between the two. It could be the exact same moment, but it's really how you're thinking about it mentally, uh, approaching it.
So yeah, that's what I see, but I'd love to get your thoughts on this too. I, I, I, feel like I struggle with this sometimes between, like modulating between the deprivation and the discipline. I've moved a lot more towards... I, I actually spend a lot more than I ever thought I would, and now I have developed this, this timeframe where like I wanted to move as far away from deprivation as I possibly could get.
And I wanted to do this experiment, and I started to do this experiment where like, okay, if I can focus on increasing my income over this, this next couple of years, and I did it over the course of like seven or so years, uh, you know, what would that look like? What would that feel like, and how would I feel if I did that?
And when I started to do it, what I realized was my priorities shifted, and they shifted in a way that I never anticipated. But I really started to prioritize things like health. I started to prioritize more so things like, uh, convenience and buying back my time and in health are like two areas of my life that I probably would have not spent money on, you know, previously.
I would've said, "Okay, well, I could go outside and run or walk or lift weights, uh, you know, at a gym membership for 20 bucks a month. Why would I prioritize, you know, other areas of my health when I could just kind of hack my way to it?" But then I realized, oh no, this is one of those things that I actually do value.
And once I got comfortable spending a little bit more and getting away from that deprivation line, it allowed me to do this. And then secondarily is I started to realize once I had kids that I wanted my time back. Hmm. I wanted more time back so I could spend more time with them, 'cause it's not worth my time or energy to like spend five hours mowing my lawn, for example, or spend two hours every weekend cleaning my pool.
And so instead, I wanted to buy that time back, which before I would spend, you know, five, seven, 10 hours a weekend on my law... I remember like waking up Saturday, and I'd be like in the yard until like 3:00 in the afternoon. I'm like, "What the heck am I doing?" So finally hired it out. It was like $60. I couldn't believe how cheap it is, and now that's- Yeah
like one of the best $60 I spend per month. And so it's one of those things that like I've developed a- and gotten closer away from that deprivation line only because I decided I wanted to try to spend more. And so I think for people listening If you're going through this, like if you're saying to yourself, "I'm pretty frugal," and this is not everybody.
Some people are on the opposite end of the spectrum, you need to spend less. But if you are someone who is overly frugal or feels as though you struggle with the skill of spending, just try to spend a little bit more on your... You know, listening to a personal finance podcast and having someone tell you to spend more is probably the opposite of what you thought was gonna happen.
But I think it does help you kind of get into the realm to figure out what some of your values are. Sometimes it's hard to know what your values are until you actually try it out, to test it out to see if it's something you really want. And so many times I would just evaluate this in a couple different ways.
But that's kind of how I got there. It may not be the right way, but that's kind of how I got there. But you gotta make sure that you're still hitting your goals. And it really for me comes down to if you're hitting your financial freedom goals, if you're hitting your savings rate goals, if your net worth is increasing every single year, you can do experiments like this.
You can do fun stuff like this, and it'll give you the ability to be able to kind of see what it's like, see what it's like to spend a little more in this area, or see what it's like... I just, we just took a, you know, a weekend trip down to The Bahamas, and I spent more in four days than I ever thought I would spend in my life.
But it was one of those things that, like I enjoyed every second of it, 'cause it was memories that we made as a family. Like, here's a great example of it, okay? Is we did the like swimming with the dolphins encounter, okay? And years ago I would have never, ever done something like this because it was like an hour long for five of us, and it was like $990.
But you got to touch the dolphin, the dolphin like kisses you on the cheek. Cool. Like you get to watch it do all these different tricks. And years ago I would have never done something like that, but like it was, my kids absolutely loved it. It was like one of the most memorable things. They're still talking about it today.
And so it's just like one of those things that you just gotta try and you just gotta do. So these are just examples that, uh, I think for many of you out there are, are really, really interesting ways to kind of think about this. When it comes to this, though, like do you think that most people need to kind of establish those baselines first?
So they need to establish that savings rate line. Do they need to establish kind of where they want their investments to be before they start to kind of spend more on some of these values? Or what is your order of operations in how you think about that? Man, you, you just named it so well right there. Uh, and listening to you give the response back to the, the last question there too, I, I do think this is really just a sequencing or an order, uh, conversation.
There are people that would really benefit from not doing the $20 me- uh, gym membership because they're working their way out of credit card debt. Just go walk outside, do some of the, the body weight free things that you can do, and that $20 is gonna give you an outsize impact on, on your budget now.
Versus, uh, someone that might be way later in their financial independence journey that has had discipline for decades, um, that has been hitting their goals, that would honestly benefit from the opposite. Spending a little bit more, um, reducing the savings rate to some degree and, and honestly finding some of the, the joy and fulfillment in spending.
Um, so yes, I'm a big fan of front loading, uh, especially this financial independence journey, really working on the savings rate, uh, from the, the get-go, and then right-sizing- using it throughout your journey and rewarding yourself as you make pro- uh, progress too. Like, it's, that's something that I think, uh, I struggle with, and I know many other people in the financial independence community have struggled with too, just moving the goalpost.
It's like you, you promised yourself that, like, this was kind of the end or you would start loosening the reins at this point in time, so you gotta start doing it at some point in time. You gotta reward yourself for all the hard work that your former self put in. For sure. And I, that's my number one struggle is that goalpost moving.
But I think for, for many people out there, you're gonna see it to where, you know, once you get to a point in time, and I think Coast FIRE is a great, great point in time where this can happen, is if you get to Coast FIRE and all of a sudden you realize, okay, well, if I slow down the amount that I'm saving, or if I just stop immediately right here, I can still coast my way, obviously, into retirement because compound interest is gonna take over, and it will get my, you know, investments all the way to the point in time where they need to go.
So that's a great first goal. For, like, anybody listening who hasn't reached Coast FIRE yet, this is a great first goal to get to, 'cause then you can start to loosen up the reins a little bit and have the ability to do some of this fun stuff. But being able to make sure that y- that savings rate is in place and, and making sure that you're kind of working towards those goals is first.
And that's why I love, you know, frontloading, just like you said. Like, that's the same thing I did, and I don't regret it, doing any of that whatsoever because it allowed me to kind of get to the point in time where I could take my foot off the gas a little bit. And you're going to really, really appreciate that your younger self did that.
I, I've never met- Definitely ... a single person that's like, "I wish I didn't save in my 20s." Like, it's, it's usually people who said, "Hey, yeah, I'm so glad I did." Maybe they will regret things like, like what you're talking about here, where they regret taking a specific trip, or they regret missing out on something.
But we all are gonna regret spending decisions, whether we overspend or we underspend. Mm-hmm. And so in reality, the better situation, I think, for most people, is to kind of frontload, uh, some of this stuff Do you think there are purchases, or maybe you have some specific ones for you, that are always worth it while you're on the path to financial independence?
I really hate to be prescriptive on this. Um, but I'll... I, I, I talk to a lot of people that have gone through financial independence, or honestly just a lot of older people in general and, and taking some wisdom from them. Uh, and it's kind of affirmed a couple of things that I feel like were always really worth it on my path to financial independence.
Um, they were travel and experiences. Uh, they were my health, uh, personal development, relationships, and safety and security. Like, any time that I spent on those, I never really regretted it. Uh, and then on the flip side, like I said, I hate to be prescriptive 'cause it's gotta be different for everybody, but, uh, there were some things that I felt like were very easy for me to avoid in my financial independence journey, especially early on when I was, um, really focused on my savings rate and reducing my expenses, and that were convenience purchases like food delivery.
Um, it was a fancy car. Uh, not a reliable car, but a fancy car. Uh, uh, new clothes. Um, housing in like the most popular area of town. Like, those were some of the things that like were easy sacrifices for me that really kind of moved the needle, uh, to, to accelerate my journey, and honestly just allow me to like then experience those a little bit later in life when, you know, now I'm in my 30s and it's nice whenever I can order some food, uh, to the house because my wife and I don't wanna go out.
Uh, you know, the $14 extra charge on it's not the end of the world versus, like I said, when I was 22, uh, just getting in the car and going to pick something up myself or making a meal at home was, was an easy sacrifice I could make Are there any, you know, questions that you think people should ask themselves or exercises people should go through where they're trying to figure out what their values actually are?
I mean, a lot of people know maybe, like, what their hobbies are or something that they're interested in. But if someone's trying to identify, 'Hey, how do I separate my values from things that I just kind of feel as though are frivolous and that I want?' Is there anything that you did to, to do that? Did you sit down and, like, write these out?
Did you sit down with, with your wife and kinda talk through this, or how did you think about it? Hmm. I wish I had a, a really good exercise for you on this, but this was, like, a lot of trial and error, uh, for me. Like, this is the thing. I, I love mini experiments, I love small experiments, and I think, um, non-consequential experiments are a great way to actually figure out your values.
You were, you were talking about this earlier where, you know, on your next trip, spend the money on the all-inclusive and, like, how does it feel? Does it feel good? Does it feel not good? Like, uh, the nice thing is that that might be, like, a $1,000 decision in that moment that you can contain. Uh, and then maybe the next month cut back, like cancel all your subscriptions.
And then at the end of the month, like, which ones were you really, like, yearning for and which ones didn't really make sense for you? Um, so I like turning things on and off, uh, and seeing, like, how does that impact me? Is that something that I miss? Is that something that I don't miss? Um, and then I think just the bigger value questions you wanna think through are, are some of the things that I talked about on the moments that matter list.
Like, where are the experience or the moments that you really wanna show up for? Uh, and, and to that regard, just trying to deprioritize, uh, money the best, uh, you can in some of those decisions. One of the areas that people worry about a lot as they're on this path is kind of thinking through lifestyle creep, and I think lifestyle creep can be something that too many people in the personal finance space may say is, like, the worst possible thing that could happen.
And for most people, that's their problem. Their problem is that, you know, death- either death by a thousand cuts or they're increasing their housing, their transportation, their, their food costs way too much, and that's why they're still living paycheck to paycheck even though they're making, you know, $200,000 per year.
You'd be shocked how many people, uh, we have done, like, some studies recently. We're looking at people who are making over $150,000 per year who are still living paycheck to paycheck, and it's over 50%, which is just wild. It's crazy. But when we think about this, is some lifestyle creep good? Like, do you think some lifestyle creep is good, or should this be something where, hey, we're kind of staying at, at one specific level no matter what we're making?
Hmm. I, I think some lifestyle creep is definitely good, especially if you're disciplined and you are hitting the marks on your financial goals. Uh, humans crave progression and progress, and there should be small rewards throughout your journey here. So, you know, kind of staying flat and, and, you know, maintaining the same kind of budget, especially in a world where everything's just getting more expensive naturally, like is gonna be so hard and so deflating in your journey.
But if you're hitting your financial goals, if you're increasing your income every single year, I do think, uh, you should take a portion of that and consider what were some of those things in my disciplined moment that I said, you know, I would like to spend money on that, but not yet. Uh, and then thinking through, okay, how can I start adding some of those things in as I progress through financial independence?
And one thing that really helped me, uh, we talk about our net worth and the 4% rule, and I always like... As I was building in this journey to financial independence, I had this like Outsized portion of money that was just sitting there in these accounts, and I really couldn't do anything with it. Like, I, I wasn't...
Like, it wasn't, like, liquid cash that I could deploy at any point in time. But it wasn't... It shouldn't be ignored either. Like, that was all the progress that I've made over this time. Uh, so what I did was, like, on my spreadsheets, you know, when I was, like, um, figuring out my, my cash flow, I'd do my income, like how much am I making this year from my, my W-2 and my business and my side hustles?
How much am I spending? Uh, and one thing that helped was just to add one more thing in my income category, and that was just, like, my, my 4% minion. Um, it was like I looked at my net worth, you know, multiplied it by 4%. That's essentially, like, we're working towards FIRE right there. But I added it to my current income.
So then that kind of like boosted up, like, what I was, um, how much money I actually could, could afford in my life. And that gave me a little bit more reassurance that, hey, Justin, like, if you're making $100,000 and you're spending 50, you got a 50% savings rate. But you also saved $200,000 over here on the side, too, and that shouldn't be ignored.
Like, you should be considering, like, how much if you were to deploy that, that little minion to your life right now, how much money that could also bring into to your life or your world right now. Uh, so I did that, and, like, I actually realized, like, oh, my income was probably more than I thought it was. It was a little bit more outsized, and that allowed me to be a little bit more comfortable slowly, gradually, um, increasing my, my lifestyle as I was also working and building my net worth up, too.
Do you have a routine that you go through? Is it, like, on a weekly basis or a monthly basis, or even just, like, what you talked about on a yearly basis, that you kind of think about managing your money when it comes to, to this stuff? Because I think sometimes, you know, if we manage our money properly, we can see how much extra we have left over in order to be able to, to spend on things that we value or things that we enjoy.
Do you use, like... Is spreadsheets the, the route that you go? Do you use, like, a money tool? Or how do you kind of do that, and what do your money routines look like? Uh, I'm an old s- old-school spreadsheet guy. Uh, probably because, like, I'm, like, a Excel, Google Sheets, uh, wizard, and I just, like, built the tool that I wanted to on, on that front.
Uh, but yeah, at the end of every single month, I, um, catalog my income and my expenses. I track my net worth. I update the accounts and, and put my net worth in there, and then I do all the small maintenance stuff, like get my se- receipts for my, my business or my HSA accounts, et cetera. Um, but yeah, I honestly think, uh, data has been king for me.
Like, it, it wasn't until I really started tracking everything and I realized, A, how much progress I was making on the net worth side, and B, honestly, how much surplus or flexibility that I had on the, the cash flow side that allowed me to actually become a little bit more comfortable running some of these mini experiments, spending some, uh, and kind of figuring out what I actually like to enjoy, uh, spending my money on.
I found that once I started to do exactly that, and I use, uh, I use Monarch Money. There's, there's a bunch of tools out there, but that's what I use. And I, I found once I started to do this, I realized, oh, this is actually kind of freeing because then all of a sudden I could kind of see the difference between my money's actually going where I want it to go fir- first.
But secondly, then I can actually kind of see the difference and kind of use those dollars towards my values or use some of these dollars towards, you know, something big that I wanna save up for. So I thought it, you know, it's a, it's a really freeing feeling for listeners who just haven't done this before or gone through this exercise to just kind of develop some sort of money routine.
Like, I have a routine where, you know, every week I kind of check the accounts. I pay off my cards every week. It just keeps me on top of everything. It's just, there's not a real reason why I do it outside of just staying on top of everything. Then every single month I just double check my transactions that they're all automated in the right c- you know, the right spots, and I kind of check my cash flow, the net worth, and all those different things.
And it really does not take long. How much time does your, your routine take you? 'Cause you're- Uh ... on spreadsheets, so you're manually doing it. It's a little bit- Yeah ... different than, than the way I do it. Hon- honestly, 20, 30 minutes a month, and some of that's just because I like to, like, overdo some things.
Like, I put the exact date in versus just, like, I probably could just put August for every single transaction that happened in August. I, I really don't run, like, a date specific reports or, or calculations. But Andrew, I am totally with you. Everyone that is starting their personal finance journey, the, the first piece of advice I give them or the first action item is just reconciling your expenses and just figuring out cash flow.
Like, what's coming in, what's going out, um, and that can be scary for some people, uh, of course. Like, but It can be very freeing for many people. Like, many people don't realize, my wife was one of those people. I started helping her years ago, uh, with her finances just when we were dating, and she, like, always said she was bad with money and she's overspending and stuff.
And then for, like, a year we tracked all of her expenses and income, and she was doing way better than she thought. And that, that piece of information, that reassurance was so freeing for her, uh, and got her really excited. And then of course there's, like, the little optimization. Whenever you're, like, looking at your expenses every single month, s- things start to show up that maybe are just on autopilot or autopay, uh, monthly ex- subscriptions and stuff.
You're like, "I don't care about that anymore. Let's get rid of that." Um, so regardless if you're doing better or you're doing worse, I think knowing where you're at in that spectrum and then getting the information is super important in your journey. And that's where I, I think it's been become popular for people to say, like, "Oh, don't, you don't need a budget.
You don't need to do all this stuff." But in reality, if you start doing that, you're gonna realize, 'cause that's about, um, as much time as I spend per month, and, and it's probably, like, right around, you know, that 30-minute mark. And most people think it's gonna take them hours, and it's not. It's just not going to once you get into this routine and once you get into the habit of doing it.
And even when you're first getting started, if this feels like a daunting task to you, you could spend five minutes every single day. And I know really, you know, people who are good with money who don't do this. Uh, but it's just one of those things where if you want to make sure that you're getting every dollar towards the things that you actually value like we're talking about here, it is just a great thing to do.
So you mentioned that, you know, the goal posts move sometimes for people, like they move for me all the time. Has your definition of enough changed, or is it something that you're... And is that something you're working on if it has? Oh, man, I think I'm always working on this. It, it's changed for good and bad.
Uh, I definitely feel more at ease with, like, how much I've saved, and honestly, just my confidence to make more money if I ever need to. Like, that's the great thing about becoming a business owner. You feel very confident in yourself that, that you can make more money if you need to. Um, but I struggle with moving the goalpost, like so many people in the community do.
You know, uh, at the beginning of my journey, I was so excited just to reach lean FIRE, and I was like, "I could do that. Like as s- I reach lean FIRE, if I make a little bit extra money on top of that, that's great. If not, like, I can live that lifestyle." And now, uh, well, getting married i- is one thing that will change that perspective a little bit, but I'm like, "Man, I wanna reach fat FIRE now."
So yeah, I, I, I feel better about my enough number, and I, I don't feel uneasy with how much I've saved, but at the same time, there are moments when I'm like... I, I, I spiral, and I'm like, "Oh, no, do I have enough? And do I need to keep saving, investing, et cetera?" Y- so you recently just got married, so congratulations publicly- Thank you
on the podcast. We've already talked about this in private, and you had a really cool wedding, which I think, uh, was, was a very, very awesome way that you did it. But when I think about, you know, managing money in a relationship, and we're doing it on the path to financial independence, have you found any challenges along the way?
And what are some of the ways that you and your wife now talk about money? Do you do, like, a money meeting? Do you just have conversations throughout the day, or how do you kind of manage money together as a couple? Yeah, luckily Gabby and I started this long before we got married. Um, we've been dating for, I think, seven or eight years at this point in time.
We've known each other for, like, 11 or 12 years, so we've had a pretty open relationship about money. I ended up being kind of like her money manager whenever she first started this, this journey of her own. Uh, and then I, I... she drank the, the FIRE Kool-Aid, and I kinda got her excited about, uh, this journey as well.
Um, but yeah, at the, uh, end of every month, I do all my reconciliation and kinda get all the numbers onto the spreadsheet, and then we come back together, and we'll look at... I'll, I'll highlight line items that I'm like, "Hey, I wanna ask you about these certain questions," or, "Hey, we need to collect a receipt for that."
Uh, and that keeps us on track. And then we just do a high-level cashflow. Like, hey, how much money has the family brought in this month? How much money, uh, is the family going out this month? What are some big purchases that are coming up in the next quarter? Uh, what are some things that we wanna continue saving for?
How are you feeling about money right now? Uh, do you feel deprived? Do you feel okay? Uh, is there anything that's changing? We'll, we'll have this open conversation every single month. Uh, and honestly, that's been helping us and, uh, she's really great at, like, the, the administrative details, so if there's, like, small things that need to get done over the next month on the money side, she can usually handle all of those, and then I kind of look big picture, uh, and just help make sure that the cash flow is w- working pretty well in our, our finances.
When you first got her on board, like you guys were having conversations about money and she used to, to feel like she was bad with money, did you make any mistakes along the way? 'Cause I... Let me just tell you why I'm asking this question, okay? The first thing I did was when I first got married, my wife and I were, uh, trying to figure out our money, and the first thing I did was at the time we were using, like, the old school YNAB that you had to manually kind of put, put everything in.
And I pulled it out, and I was like, "Look at this. We're overspending it here, here, and here, and this is crazy," yada, yada, yada. And that, I can tell you right now, that's the wrong way to do it. Uh, it's no- instead, what I realized was, like, pretty quickly I need to start to have these conversations in a way where I'm kind of showing the outcome.
And so, "Hey, if we do this, we can become financially free at this age," or, "If we do this, we can take X amount more vacations." And that's what we really wanted. That's what we both really wanted. But I was looking at the nuance and showing, you know, just kind of placing blame. And I was young then. We got married when, you know, in our early 20s, so it was one of those things where I was also immature.
But at the same time, I think that was w- uh, something that, uh, I learned a lesson that day. And it was basically, hey, let's focus on our goals and what we want and our why, and then we can work backwards from there. Did you make any mistakes along the way doing that, or were you kind of already, you know, in a, in a point in time where you kind of knew how to handle this?
Andrew, I feel so seen by you. That was my exact problem. Uh, I think ultimately it was just assuming that people look at and view money the same way I view and look at money. And, uh, for me, I was the spreadsheet guy and the optimization guy, and, uh, you know, if you cut these certain things out, you could save this much amount of money.
But yeah, you're right. I, I wasn't putting the why behind it. I wasn't really looking at what Gabby really wanted from, from money. And, and it took me a while to really sort that out, but she kept telling... I, like, I kept asking her, like, why she wanted to get good with her expenses, and I, I found out, like, she wanted to make a career pivot.
And she wanted to feel confident that she could step out of this job that was paying her very well and step into a different job, uh, and, and really have the safety and security that comes along with, uh, a healthy savings and, uh, good financial practices. And whenever I started painting that for her and her being able to make this change and that she's gonna be okay, that's when things really clicked, and she started to get excited.
And then she kind of moved me out of the way, and she just managed her money her, her own way. So yeah, I think I, I beat my head on it multiple times trying to convince her about savings rate and the 4% rule and, and financial independence and all of that, and I, I really just needed to paint it for how she wanted money to, to act in her life at that time.
Exactly. I think that's, that's a big key. And I know for many listeners and many people even in, in, you know, that we talk to in our, our, uh, academy and things like that, they all kind of mention this. They're just trying to get on the same page, and I think it's just so important to paint that picture, paint the outcome, uh, and kind of get everybody on that same page.
And all of a sudden it's just gonna work out. It'll work out in your favor. Having those regular meetings and kind of making sure that you both are on the same page I think is super important, too. And this doesn't have to be, like, a, you know, we're gonna sit down, and we're gonna have PowerPoints and TV.
You could sit down with, like, you know, a glass of wine and kind of enjoy the timeframe. It doesn't have to be this whole strenuous thing. Uh, but instead you can actually kind of try to make it fun, and I think that's one of the cool things when it comes to, to some of this stuff, is just making sure you're communicating, like anything in a marriage.
Uh, but also just making sure that you, in your relationship, you're just trying to go th- towards the thing that you both actually want, which I think is, is so important. Definitely. Yeah, and I think, um, both partners being involved in the finances to some degree is also really important because I think there have been moments that Gabby's just been like, "You just do it all."
Uh, and I've realized that I want us both involved, both invested. Although we do- both have different roles and responsibilities whenever it comes to the family finances, um, we both ultimately know what's happening a- and, um, we're both taking some responsibility for that. For sure, and I think that's the, that's the huge key overall.
Well, Justin, this has been absolutely amazing. I c- appreciate you so much for coming on here. I know our listeners are gonna love this as well. Can you tell our listeners where they can find out more about you, your podcast, and everything else you have going on? Yeah. If, uh, you wanna achieve financial independence and have fun along the way, I host a podcast all about that.
It's called FI Minded, or FI Minded, anywhere you listen to podcasts. Uh, if you love Andrew, uh, I've had him on the show a couple of times, so just search FI Minded Andrew Giancola, and his episodes will show up. Awesome. Well, we will link all of those down below in the show notes so that you guys can check that out.
Justin, thank you again so much for coming on here. Andrew, it's been a blast. Thanks for having me, man